Media Release - Appeal Decision (Noga v Verdouw & SoT)

Appeal dismissed: damages award upheld

Terminally ill abuse survivor's $1.64m damages award upheld after Tasmania Supreme Court Appeal

Angela Sdrinis Legal acted for a terminally ill survivor of historical child sexual abuse who had her $1.64 million damages award upheld by the Court of Appeal comprising Justice Pearce, Justice Jago and Acting Justice Slattery following an appeal by her former teacher at Hobart Matriculation College, Stephen Fane Noga, in Tasmania on 16 November 2026.

Shortly prior to the original trial before Justice Estcourt, which was conducted in February 2026, the Plaintiff was diagnosed with a severe neurological disorder as a result of which she has a shortened life expectancy and, during the trial, she experienced difficulties in speaking and required the use of a wheelchair.

The 22-day trial was brutal, featuring six and a half days of rigorous cross-examination, and severely aggravated the Plaintiff’s physical and psychiatric injuries which were already a significant burden.

Noga’s conduct in defending the original claim was so egregious that Justice Estcourt awarded exemplary damages in the sum of $200,000 against him personally. In doing so, Justice Estcourt said that this award should take into account the conduct of Noga’s case which involved assertions by him that the Plaintiff was perjuring herself with a view to fraudulently obtaining compensation.

The award of damages by Justice Estcourt gave the Plaintiff assurance that justice could be done in a case that required all of her strength, courage and resilience to survive.

Shortly after Justice Estcourt handed down his decision on 20 April 2026, the Plaintiff was informed by her neurologist that she was expected to die from her condition within the next 12 months. Notwithstanding this devastating news, the Plaintiff finally felt closure.

However, this relief was short-lived as on 6 May 2026, Noga filed a Notice of Appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Tasmania.

Noga’s legal team relied on four appeal points:

1.    Apprehended bias on the part of the trial judge evidenced in a series of face book posts referencing instances of child sexual abuse;

2, 3 & 4.  Being alleged errors in the way the trial judge directed himself and addressed the evidence.

Points 2, 3 & 4 were dismissed in full. Regarding appeal point 1, whilst any right minded person is appalled by instances of child sexual abuse, the Court of Appeal emphasized that the test is not whether the trial judge was actually biased but whether there was a possibility that a fair minded lay observer might reasonably apprehend that the judge might not bring an impartial mind to the resolution of the question the judge is required to decide.

Ultimately the Court of Appeal found that because Noga and his legal team failed to act promptly on becoming aware of a circumstance constituting grounds to object, this resulted in waiver. The Court of Appeal cited with favour the following:

“It cannot be the position that a party can wait to see whether the outcome of a case is favourable to him before raising an objection, the availability of which he was previously aware on the grounds of bias.”

Whilst the Plaintiff is relieved that Noga’s appeal was dismissed, she highlighted concerns about the State’s conduct.

Whilst the State did not file an Appeal, it did attempt to utilise Noga’s Appeal as a vehicle to avoid or delay paying the Plaintiff the damages for which it was held jointly and severally liable. On 22 May 2026, the State applied for, and was granted, an order (‘stay order’) that it not be required to pay the damages of $1,444,817.02 because its application to extend time to file a Notice of Contribution against Noga had not yet been heard and determined.

The extension of time application only arose because the State failed to file a Notice of Contribution against Noga in accordance with the Supreme Court Rules. On 26 August 2026, the Court of Appeal lifted the stay order despite objections raised by the State which wanted it to remain in place until contribution proceedings had resolved against Noga. This could have taken years in circumstances where the State were well aware of the Plaintiff’s limited life expectancy.

In taking this position, the State intentionally deprived the Plaintiff of the opportunity to enjoy her award of damages for over four months during which time her health significantly declined and her capacity to enjoy life diminished every day.

The Plaintiff hopes that she may finally be able to close this chapter. Going forward, the Plaintiff implores the State to fulfil the promises it made to victims of sexual abuse in response to the Independent Inquiry into the Tasmanian Department of Education’s Responses to Child Sexual Abuse Final Report of 7 June 2021 and its Model Litigant Guidelines.

Ms Ellen FitzGerald, solicitor for the Plaintiff, said, “Whilst our common law system is adversarial in nature, the State of Tasmania can take steps to reduce trauma to survivors whilst still appropriately representing the interests of Tasmanian taxpayers."

 

Angela Sdrinis Legal

16 November 2026

Next
Next

Former Hobart teacher Stephen Noga loses appeal against civil child sexual abuse decision